Who should i go with ?
Quotations are within £2.50 of each other with same excesses (£250 Accidental Damage, Fire and Theft excess, windscreen cover £60 excess)

save your £2.50 mate

Well I got a similar quote from both (£720 from Noel Dazely and £757 from Greenlight) However my first payment with Noel D. would have been £250 to cover their underwriters costs whereas With Greenlight it would be just £150. So it's greenlight all the way for me.

Sainsbury's beat both quotes but did include a £250 voluntary excess so i'll probably still go with one of the other two. Struggling with ND though- the proposal form they faxed me had so many discrepancies in it compared to the info i gave them and i'm still waiting for them to sort it out.

Check who the actual insurance policies will be with. As they are both brokers you'll find that the different insurance companies they use will have different terms and conditions.

thanks, but i've already decided to go to ND

they seem good. ive got my cheapest quote yet through them.

Noel Dazeley wins my preference..

However those who have claimed would be the better judges as which insurer will actually pay out, how they handles the claim, the speed of turnaround and additional fringe benefits.

noel dazely use ensign, ensign are actually ok at handling claims. ND always. You get Noel Dazely Uninsured loss recovery who are excellent. I have used them twice now for my legal cover and they are amazing.

Definitely Noel Dazely - excellent service

Personally id go with noel dazely.. they have by far come up as the cheapest...
greenlight wouldnt even insure me!!

Yep same for me greenlight were not impressive where as ND and Adrian Flux were. But ND had much better service A1 to them go ND

So it's safe to say in summary, phone both, and they will tell you how much money they want to insure you

fancy that hey