Ah, hang on, I've remembered Privilege don't know about my points yet (I did mention them in an unrelated phone call before but they just told me to tell them at renewal time).

So I suspect ND will still be best...

Just phoned around for my insurance and ND came out top ... and by quite a long way ... nearly £100 better than the requote from my existing insurers

Another benefit of joining the forum (I'd not have come across the list of insurers otherwise)

I've also gone with ND but watch the small print- if you need to use yor car in connection with your work/business you'll need to ask for this. My previous insurer included this as standard.